In personal finance mistakes, no less than 13 questions I repeatedly come across that one should never ask. Questions like how much of your salary should you save? Where should you invest? Should you buy a house or live on rent? Is a stock market crash always a buying opportunity? How much money is enough for retirement?
Among the most frequently asked questions in personal finance, most of the questions are so generic that it leads you to wrong & misleading answers. And the biggest financial mistake is not getting the wrong answer, but asking the wrong question in the first place?
I have examined 13 common financial questions that often lead to misleading advice, unsuitable investment decisions, and costly financial mistakes.
I call them DNA Questions – Do Not Ask!
Why? Because personal finance is PERSONAL. Your income, age, expenses, liabilities, family responsibilities, existing assets, lifestyle, and risk tolerance determine what makes financial sense for you.
Yet, the financial advice industry often promotes universal formulas and ready-made solutions. Are these recommendations genuinely designed to improve your financial health, or do they sometimes serve the commercial interests of financial product sellers?
And why am I pointing out these questions in the first place? It’s because your quest for wrong questions land you with wrong answers, wrong solutions and only beneficiary is some vested interest who has to sell or promote something.
#1. How much salary to save & invest?
These can be no one-size-fits-all answer. There are many variables like – your age; expenses; financial liability; and whether you have any inheritance or not. How could everyone have the same thumb rule of say 15 or 20 or 25%, as advised by some finfluencers. The advice so because they have to sell something, mostly the financial assets or insurance products.
#2. Where to invest?
In order to understand this, please remember – you are the variable factor with this question. Who are you? Asset class allocation for any individual needs personalized portfolio analysis. It’s like you ask a doctor that for a common allergic flu, whether you should take Crocin or Allegra as medicine. How could he advice without a personalized diagnosis? Same is true with financial investment as well.
#3. Should I buy this property or live on rent?
It depends on your net worth & stage o life. Actually this question itself has two different meaning: whether the given housing project that you wish to buy is legally clear & right priced; and secondly whether you can afford to buy. MIND YOU! Here I am talking about whether or not you can afford and it doesn’t mean whether you pass loan eligibility test.
#4. Which city is best for investment?
How can a third party tell you where you feel more comfortable; which city fits into your budget; where you would like to settle, work & retire. So, this is one question that you need to ask yourself.
#5. Isn’t market crash/correction always an opportunity?
My clear answer: No! Only right investment product with strong fundamentals is right buy in market crash and in the market crash/correction it is never a case of everything on sale.
#6. Should I buy a house or live on rent?
For such a question, I have a counter question: Do you have net worth to buy a house? If you have a net worth, and some 30-40% of that net worth qualifies you to buy a house, then go and buy a house. But you should never assume your loan eligibility as real affordability? And, needless, to add, if you don’t have financial bandwidth, don’t buy a house. Living on rent is not a crime, or social stigma, by any stretch of imagination.
#7. How much percentage of income should be spared on home loan EMI?
Again, no one size fits all answer. It depends upon how much share of your income goes into living expense – it could be 20% or even 80%. Similarly, your choice of property would define how much your income goes into your home loan EMI. As a thumb rule, if you an average salaried Indian, don’t spend more than 40% of your income on home loan EMI.
#8. Should I opt for pre-payment of home loan or invest that money?
This is again a very personalized choice. Ask yourself: Is your home loan leverage or liability? If you have corpus and your home loan is for leveraging your capital with lowest possible home loan interest rate, then equation changes. But if your home loan is making you sacrifice other expenses, then pre-pay. Also, keep in mind tax implications, if you an average salaried person.
#9. Please help me against this builder cheating?
This is one question that I get repeatedly, of course, with a request to help. And it’s not that I don’t wish to help or get involved. I do! I am not scared to take a defaulter builder head-on in exposing. But I can’t fight someone else’s battle, when one is himself not ready to fight. So, I have a question in such cases: Have you filed the case? And the reply disappoints me: No! builder is very powerful? Well, in that case, is media de facto consumer court? What if this very powerful builder files case against me? If you can’t fight for yourself, how could & why should someone else fight for you?
#10. How much is enough for retirement?
This is one more such generic question that has a prime variable component in you as a person. The answer depends upon many variables – city; liabilities; health condition; lifestyle; & your overall expenses.
#11. How much is enough for emergency fund?
This is a genuine question but more often than not wrongly asked. I need to diagnose as to how secure is your job or business? How desirable you are in the market? How fast you think you could get another job or business, if present one disappears? One-size-fits-all answer is not possible.
#12. How much should be health insurance amount?
This should be no brainer answer, but still asked. What is your age and health conditions, that matters. Family history of disease comes into play – BP, Sugar, Heart.
#13. Is a financial advisor worth paying?
This is a smart question but doesn’t demand generic answer. So, my answer normally is: Yes & No! You should pay for advice only. You approach a financial advisor to get educated, get right advice that doesn’t lead you to investment where this advisor-cum-salesman is getting commission. Advice means pure play fee-based advice only.
I hope I have clarified on most of the generic questions on personal finance & investment. Any such generic question that you face? Feel free to comment!
Ravi Sinha